Whole buttermilk vs Malt milkshake

In short

One serving each: 152 calories in whole buttermilk (1 cup, 245 g), 280 calories in malt milkshake (8 fl oz, 224 g). More in whole buttermilk: vitamin D, selenium and sodium.

More in malt milkshake: saturated fat, cholesterol, total fat, carbohydrates (2.6×) and vitamin B6. Everything else is within 4% of a day's needs.

Calories, and where they come from

Whole buttermilk152 cal

1 cup (245 g) · 7.9 g protein · 12 g carbs (12 g sugars) · 8.1 g fat

Malt milkshake280 cal

8 fl oz (224 g) · 8.4 g protein · 30.6 g carbs (27 g sugars) · 13.7 g fat

Share of the calories fromproteincarbsfat

Where they differ

Each dot is the share of a day's needs (FDA Daily Value) in one serving of each. Every row uses the same scale, so a short gap is a small difference. Color says which food, never which is better.

0%25%50%
  • Saturated fatlimit23% vs 41%

    4.7 g vs 8.2 g

  • Cholesterollimit9% vs 17%

    26.9 mg vs 51.5 mg

  • Total fat10% vs 18%

    8.1 g vs 13.7 g

  • Vitamin D16% vs 9%

    3.2 µg vs 1.8 µg

  • Carbohydrates4% vs 11%

    12 g vs 30.6 g

  • Selenium16% vs 10%

    9.1 µg vs 5.4 µg

  • Sodiumlimit11% vs 6%

    257 mg vs 148 mg

  • Vitamin B65% vs 9%

    0.088 mg vs 0.16 mg

Show as: bars · dots

Where they are alike

Less than 4% of a day apart, in one serving of each.

  • Protein7.9 g · 8.4 g16%·17%
  • Fiber0 g · 0.45 g0%·2%
  • Potassium331 mg · 426 mg7%·9%
  • Calcium282 mg · 293 mg22%·23%
  • Iron0.073 mg · 0.13 mg<1%·1%
  • Magnesium24.5 mg · 35.8 mg6%·9%
  • Phosphorus208 mg · 251 mg17%·20%
  • Zinc0.93 mg · 1.2 mg8%·11%
  • Copper0.061 mg · 0.036 mg7%·4%
  • Vitamin A115 µg · 141 µg13%·16%
  • Vitamin C0 mg · 0.67 mg0%·1%
  • Vitamin E0.17 mg · 0.34 mg1%·2%
  • Vitamin K0.73 µg · 1.1 µg1%·1%
  • Thiamin (B1)0.12 mg · 0.15 mg10%·13%
  • Riboflavin (B2)0.42 mg · 0.45 mg32%·35%
  • Niacin (B3)0.22 mg · 0.68 mg1%·4%
  • Folate12.3 µg · 6.7 µg3%·2%
  • Vitamin B121.1 µg · 1.1 µg47%·47%
  • Choline35.8 mg · 49.5 mg7%·9%

Reported for only one of the two, so not compared: manganese, pantothenic acid (B5).

From USDA FoodData Central: Whole buttermilk (SR Legacy 172225), Malt milkshake (Survey (FNDDS) 2705507). Daily Values are the FDA's for adults and children 4 years and older. Missing values are never shown as zero. For exploring the data, not dietary advice.

vs