Thick vanilla milkshake vs Malt milkshake

In short

One serving each: 351 calories in thick vanilla milkshake (1 container (11 oz), 313 g), 280 calories in malt milkshake (8 fl oz, 224 g). Most of the calories in thick vanilla milkshake come from carbohydrate.

More in thick vanilla milkshake: vitamin B12, copper (4.5×), calcium, riboflavin and 5 more. More in malt milkshake: saturated fat, vitamin A, total fat, thiamin and cholesterol. Everything else is within 4% of a day's needs.

Calories, and where they come from

Thick vanilla milkshake351 cal

1 container (11 oz) (313 g) · 12.1 g protein · 55.6 g carbs (55.6 g sugars) · 9.5 g fat

Malt milkshake280 cal

8 fl oz (224 g) · 8.4 g protein · 30.6 g carbs (27 g sugars) · 13.7 g fat

Share of the calories fromproteincarbsfat

Where they differ

Each dot is the share of a day's needs (FDA Daily Value) in one serving of each. Every row uses the same scale, so a short gap is a small difference. Color says which food, never which is better.

0%37.5%75%
  • Vitamin B1268% vs 47%

    1.6 µg vs 1.1 µg

  • Copper18% vs 4%

    0.16 mg vs 0.036 mg

  • Calcium35% vs 23%

    457 mg vs 293 mg

  • Riboflavin (B2)47% vs 35%

    0.61 mg vs 0.45 mg

  • Saturated fatlimit30% vs 41%

    5.9 g vs 8.2 g

  • Vitamin D19% vs 9%

    3.8 µg vs 1.8 µg

  • Carbohydrates20% vs 11%

    55.6 g vs 30.6 g

  • Phosphorus29% vs 20%

    360 mg vs 251 mg

  • Protein24% vs 17%

    12.1 g vs 8.4 g

  • Vitamin A9% vs 16%

    78.3 µg vs 141 µg

  • Sodiumlimit13% vs 6%

    297 mg vs 148 mg

  • Total fat12% vs 18%

    9.5 g vs 13.7 g

  • Thiamin (B1)8% vs 13%

    0.094 mg vs 0.15 mg

  • Cholesterollimit13% vs 17%

    37.6 mg vs 51.5 mg

Show as: bars · dots

Where they are alike

Less than 4% of a day apart, in one serving of each.

  • Fiber0 g · 0.45 g0%·2%
  • Potassium573 mg · 426 mg12%·9%
  • Iron0.31 mg · 0.13 mg2%·1%
  • Magnesium37.6 mg · 35.8 mg9%·9%
  • Zinc1.2 mg · 1.2 mg11%·11%
  • Selenium7.2 µg · 5.4 µg13%·10%
  • Vitamin C0 mg · 0.67 mg0%·1%
  • Vitamin E0.16 mg · 0.34 mg1%·2%
  • Vitamin K0.63 µg · 1.1 µg1%·1%
  • Niacin (B3)0.46 mg · 0.68 mg3%·4%
  • Vitamin B60.13 mg · 0.16 mg8%·9%
  • Folate21.9 µg · 6.7 µg5%·2%
  • Choline44.8 mg · 49.5 mg8%·9%

Reported for only one of the two, so not compared: manganese, pantothenic acid (B5).

From USDA FoodData Central: Thick vanilla milkshake (SR Legacy 170884), Malt milkshake (Survey (FNDDS) 2705507). Daily Values are the FDA's for adults and children 4 years and older. Missing values are never shown as zero. For exploring the data, not dietary advice.

vs